I think the writer has a good idea of his characters and where he wants to go with them. The descriptions are detailed enough and he actually has a story to tell instead of the crap I read before this that was mainly a racist rant masquerading as a story.
He mostly suffers from the new writers disease. It's when you fail to see the need for either editing or rewriting. You think every word you write is perfect even with the spelling errors and redundancy of names and "ands" and "hads"
I assured him we've all been there and expect good things from him in the future.
It's a hard thing reviewing others work. You have to be careful not to make their stuff yours, in the sense that your criticism forces your style on to them.
I mainly stress flow and brevity.
I'll be doing many more hopefully with more detail.